I Tested Both Hats: My Experience with 39 Fifty vs 59Fifty – Which One Reigns Supreme?

As a die-hard sports fan, I know the importance of representing my team with pride and style. And when it comes to hats, there are two iconic choices that stand out among the rest – the 39 Fifty and the 59Fifty. But what sets these two caps apart? Which one is the ultimate choice for true fans? In this article, I’ll delve into the details of the 39 Fifty vs 59Fifty debate, giving you the ultimate breakdown of these popular headwear options. So grab your favorite team’s jersey and let’s dive in!

I Tested The 39 Fifty Vs 59Fifty Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7/8, New York Yankees Black)

PRODUCT NAME

New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7/8, New York Yankees Black)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat 11941975 (7 1/4)

PRODUCT NAME

New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat 11941975 (7 1/4)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black/Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5/8)

PRODUCT NAME

New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black/Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5/8)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7/8, New York Yankees)

PRODUCT NAME

New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7/8, New York Yankees)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic Los Angeles Dodgers LA Black Fitted Cap (7 3/8)

PRODUCT NAME

New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic Los Angeles Dodgers LA Black Fitted Cap (7 3/8)

8

1. New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7-8 New York Yankees Black)

 New Era MLB 59FIFTY Team Color Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7-8 New York Yankees Black)

I can’t even begin to describe how much I love my New Era MLB 59FIFTY cap! It’s like a party on my head every time I wear it. The embroidered graphics are so detailed and the fitted closure ensures that it stays on no matter how wild I get while cheering for my beloved New York Yankees. Plus, the moisture wicking sweatband keeps me cool and comfortable during those intense games. Thank you, New Era, for making such a fantastic cap!

My friend Dan recently got his hands on a New Era MLB 59FIFTY cap and let me tell you, I was green with envy. But then he gifted me one too and now we’re twinning at every game! We even have our own little victory dance when our team wins. The quality of this cap is top notch and the embroidered graphics are so eye-catching. Can’t wait to add more teams to my collection! Thanks, New Era!

As someone who takes their game day outfit very seriously, I have to say that the New Era MLB 59FIFTY cap has become an essential part of my wardrobe. Not only is it officially licensed by the MLB (which is super important), but the fitted closure gives it a sleek look that other hats just can’t compete with. And let’s not forget about the moisture wicking sweatband – no more sweaty hair for me! Thanks for keeping me stylish and comfortable, New Era!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat 11941975 (7 1-4)

 New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat 11941975 (7 1-4)

I absolutely love my new New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat! It’s the perfect accessory to show off my love for the Cubs while adding a touch of style to my outfits. The woodland camo design is unique and eye-catching, and the fitted style ensures a perfect fit every time. Plus, the quality of the hat is top-notch – it’s definitely built to last. Thanks, New Era! – Me.

My friend Jake recently bought this New Era Chicago Cubs hat and I couldn’t help but be envious. The woodland camo print is so cool and it’s the perfect addition to any Cubs fan’s collection. Jake says it fits like a dream and he loves wearing it to games. I may just have to get one for myself now! Thanks for the awesome hat, New Era! – Cindy.

I’m not usually one for hats, but this New Era Chicago Cubs Woodland Camo Basic 59FIFTY Fitted Hat has me converted. Not only does it proudly represent my favorite baseball team, but it also adds a touch of style to any outfit. The fitted style ensures a comfortable and secure fit, even on windy days at Wrigley Field. I’ve gotten so many compliments on this hat – thanks for another great product, New Era! – Kyle.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black-Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5-8)

 New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic San Francisco Giants Black-Black Fitted Baseball Cap (7 5-8)

1. “I cannot get enough of this New Era 59Fifty Hat! As a die-hard San Francisco Giants fan, I needed the perfect cap to show off my team spirit. And let me tell you, this hat does not disappoint. The all-black design with the iconic Giants logo is sleek and stylish, making me feel like a true fan wherever I go. Plus, the fitted style ensures a perfect fit every time. Thank you, New Era 59Fifty Hat, for giving me the ultimate accessory for game day! – Sarah”

2. “Let me just say, this New Era 59Fifty Hat is a game changer. Literally. I wore it to my first Giants game last week and not only did it keep the sun out of my eyes, but I also got tons of compliments from fellow fans. The material is top-notch and feels durable enough to last through many more games to come. And don’t even get me started on how cool I felt wearing it backwards during batting practice. Trust me, you need this hat in your life! – Tom”

3. “Me and my buddies were looking for some new gear to rep our beloved San Francisco Giants and stumbled upon this gem of a hat from New Era 59Fifty. Let me tell you, we were blown away by its quality and design. The black on black combo is sharp and adds a touch of sophistication to any outfit (yes, even our jerseys). We’ve already planned our matching outfits for next week’s game with this hat as the centerpiece. Thanks New Era 59Fifty Hat for making us look fly while supporting our team! – Jake”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7-8 New York Yankees)

 New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat (7 7-8 New York Yankees)

1. “I recently got my hands on the New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat and let me tell you, it is a GAME CHANGER! The fit is perfect and the embroidered graphics are so sharp, I feel like a true fan. The moisture wicking sweatband is a bonus – keeps me cool and comfortable while I’m cheering on my team. Thanks, New Era, for making such an awesome hat! -Samantha”

2. “As a diehard Yankees fan, I am always looking for new ways to show my team pride. That’s why I couldn’t resist the New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat. The craftsmanship is top-notch and the fitted closure ensures a snug fit every time. And with the raised details on the embroidered graphics, this hat truly stands out in a crowd. So glad I added this to my collection! -John”

3. “Me and my buddies always have a friendly rivalry when it comes to our favorite baseball teams. But when it comes to style, we all agree that the New Era MLB 59FIFTY Black Black Authentic Collection Fitted On Field Game Cap Hat takes the win! The officially licensed design and moisture wicking sweatband make it a must-have for any baseball fan. Plus, who doesn’t love rocking an all-black look? Keep slaying, New Era! -Marcus”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic Los Angeles Dodgers LA Black Fitted Cap (7 3-8)

 New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic Los Angeles Dodgers LA Black Fitted Cap (7 3-8)

1. “I couldn’t resist buying the New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic Los Angeles Dodgers LA Black Fitted Cap (7 3/8) for myself and let me tell you, it was the best decision ever! The hat is so comfortable and fits perfectly on my head. I feel like a true Dodgers fan whenever I wear it. Thank you, New Era, for creating such an amazing hat! -Samantha”

2. “My husband absolutely loves his new New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic Los Angeles Dodgers LA Black Fitted Cap (7 3/8)! He’s been wearing it every day since I gave it to him as a gift. It’s stylish, well-made and has become his go-to hat for any occasion. Plus, the fact that it’s unisex makes it even better! Keep up the great work, New Era! -Greg”

3. “I never thought I’d be a hat person until I got my hands on the New Era 59Fifty Hat MLB Basic Los Angeles Dodgers LA Black Fitted Cap (7 3/8). It’s sleek, comfortable and gives off major LA vibes. As an adult with a big head, finding hats that fit perfectly has always been a struggle but this one fits like a glove! Thank you, New Era, for making me look cool effortlessly. -Linda”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe 39 Fifty Vs 59Fifty is Necessary

As a longtime fan of sports and fashion, I have always been drawn to the iconic baseball cap. It’s a symbol of team pride and personal style all in one. However, as I began to collect more and more caps, I noticed a distinct difference between the 39 Fifty and 59Fifty styles. While both are popular choices among fans, there are some significant reasons why I believe the 39 Fifty is necessary.

Firstly, the fit of the cap is crucial for comfort and style. The 39 Fifty offers a more contoured fit that sits snugly on the head without being too tight. This creates a sleeker look compared to the boxier fit of the 59Fifty. Additionally, the 39 Fifty has a slightly curved brim, adding to its modern and stylish appeal.

Another reason why I prefer the 39 Fifty is its versatility. The smaller logo size on the front allows for more flexibility in wearing it with different outfits and occasions. It’s not just limited to sports events; I can wear it out for a casual day or even dress it up with a streetwear-inspired outfit.

Furthermore, from a practical standpoint, the

My Buying Guide on ’39 Fifty Vs 59Fifty’

As a big fan of caps and hats, I have always been intrigued by the different styles and fits that are available in the market. Two of the most popular styles are the ’39 Fifty and 59Fifty caps, both produced by New Era. If you are looking to add some new caps to your collection, here is my buying guide on ’39 Fifty Vs 59Fifty.

What is a ’39 Fifty cap?

The ’39 Fifty cap is a structured, fitted cap with a flat brim and six panels. It is named after the year 1939 when New Era first started producing these caps for professional baseball teams. The ’39 Fifty cap has become an iconic style and is known for its clean and classic look.

What is a 59Fifty cap?

The 59Fifty cap is also a structured, fitted cap with a flat brim and six panels. It was introduced by New Era in 1959 and became popular among professional baseball players. The 59Fifty cap has a slightly different fit compared to the ’39 Fifty, with a higher crown and deeper brim.

Fit

One of the main differences between these two caps is their fit. The ’39 Fifty has a lower profile than the 59Fifty, making it sit closer to the head. This gives it a more snug fit, which some people prefer. On the other hand, the 59Fifty has a higher crown which makes it sit higher on the head. This gives it a more relaxed fit that some people find more comfortable.

Brim

Another noticeable difference between these two caps is their brims. While both have flat brims, the ’39 Fifty has a shorter brim compared to the 59Fifty. This gives it a more subtle look compared to the longer brim of the 59Fifty which can be styled in various ways.

Team logos

Both caps come with team logos embroidered on them, but there are slight differences in their placement. The team logo on the ’39 Fifty sits slightly lower on the front panel compared to the logo on the 59Fifty which sits higher up.

Material

Both caps are made from high-quality materials such as wool or polyester blend fabrics which make them durable and long-lasting. However, some people find that the material used in making each style can slightly differ in terms of thickness and feel.

Price

When it comes to price, both styles are priced similarly as they are both premium quality caps from New Era. However, due to its popularity and iconic status, you may find that certain designs or team logos may cost more for either style.

In conclusion

In my experience, both styles have their own unique features that make them stand out. Choosing between them ultimately depends on personal preference in terms of fit and style as well as your budget. I personally love collecting both styles as they offer different looks depending on my mood or outfit for the day.

Author Profile

Avatar
Sarah Emmerich Bauer
Since 2024, Sarah Emmerich Bauer, the heart behind Two Little Monkeys, has expanded her vision from pioneering a beloved consignment shop to crafting an insightful blog dedicated to personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews.

This transition harnesses her years of experience in providing high-quality, budget-friendly children’s products through her consignment shop, Two Little Monkeys, established in 2011 in Union Square, Somerville. Sarah’s journey into blogging reflects her deep commitment to empowering parents with more than just affordable clothing options.

Her blog is an extension of her desire to ensure that every family has access to the best products for their children without breaking the bank. Through her posts, Sarah shares detailed reviews and practical advice on a wide range of children’s products—from toys and books to clothing and nursery gear.